
Haludaria fasciata
22-26 °C
6-6.5
6 cm
5 years
This page carried the wrong scientific name for a long time. The melon barb is Haludaria fasciata, described by Jerdon in 1849 and shuffled through Puntius and Dravidia since; Pethia fasciata, the name this entry used to carry, is not a species FishBase recognises. It is endemic to the Western Ghats of southern India, in rivers of Goa, Karnataka, Kerala and Tamil Nadu, and not to Sri Lanka as the old entry claimed.
The published water figures are tight: pH 6.0-6.5, hardness near 5 dGH, and 22-26 °C. The temperature ceiling is the part worth acting on, because this barb is often sold as a warm-water community fish and kept several degrees above it.
Body size needs a caveat. The catalogue lists it as reaching 6 cm, a figure that comes from the Wikipedia species article citing FishBase's October 2013 version, which does not say whether the measurement is standard or total length. The current FishBase page prints no maximum-length row at all, and the 8 cm this entry carried before had no source behind it.
Tank volume and group size on this page are editorial. Neither source recommends either, so we suggest 100 litres and six or more fish on the ordinary grounds that a shoaling barb colours and behaves better in numbers. Males in condition flush red and grow fine tubercles on the snout, and the species scatters eggs over the substrate and then ignores them.
Figures on this page were read off these pages. Manufacturers and databases do change or retire pages; if a link is dead, tell us with the correction link below.
Pairwise screening against other species in the database (prioritizing the same family when data is available).
Review first (5)
Caution or avoid from automated rules — confirm before mixing.
| Species | Assessment | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Chinese Bitterling Rhodeus ocellatus Caution | Caution | Species with non-overlapping pH ranges may not thrive together Open pair in Compare → |
| Denison barb Sahyadria denisonii Caution | Caution | Species with non-overlapping pH ranges may not thrive together Open pair in Compare → |
| Flying fox Epalzeorhynchos kalopterum Caution | Caution | Fish 2x+ larger may eat smaller tankmates Open pair in Compare → |
| Least rasbora Boraras urophthalmoides Caution | Caution | Fish 2x+ larger may eat smaller tankmates Open pair in Compare → |
| Tinfoil barb Barbonymus schwanenfeldii Caution | Caution | Fish 2x+ larger may eat smaller tankmates · Species with non-overlapping pH ranges may not thrive together Open pair in Compare → |
| Species | Assessment | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Black ruby barb Pethia nigrofasciata Compatible | Compatible | No rule-based conflicts detected for this pair. Open pair in Compare → |
| Blackline rasbora Rasbora borapetensis Compatible | Compatible | No rule-based conflicts detected for this pair. Open pair in Compare → |
| Cherry barb Puntius titteya Compatible | Compatible | No rule-based conflicts detected for this pair. Open pair in Compare → |
| Clown rasbora Rasbora kalochroma Compatible | Compatible | No rule-based conflicts detected for this pair. Open pair in Compare → |
| Fiveband barb Desmopuntius pentazona Compatible | Compatible | No rule-based conflicts detected for this pair. Open pair in Compare → |
| Red Cherry Rasbora Rasbora lacrimula Compatible | Compatible | No rule-based conflicts detected for this pair. Open pair in Compare → |
| Rosy barb Pethia conchonius Compatible | Compatible | No rule-based conflicts detected for this pair. Open pair in Compare → |
Same rule engine as Compare. Not a substitute for observation, tank size, or acclimation.
Keep this species? Spot anything off?